ETHAN ROY'S REVIEW OF AVATAR: PERFECT CGI / IMPERFECT STORY
With Avatar, James Cameron finally perfects CGI, but does he perfect storytelling, NO. The story has been done thousands of times, Dances with Wolves, District 9, Last Samurai, and a little bit of Ferngully. James Cameron came out saying that this will be the greatest movie ever made; it’s far from it. Now is it a bad movie, no it is an incredible film, but the story is meh. The effects will obviously win an Academy Award, but James Cameron shouldn’t win any awards for this.
Already before the release the film got Golden Globes for best writing, Director, and best drama. No I feel that people shouldn’t let their experience take a hold of them saying that it is the greatest film ever, believe me I had an amazing experience, but I can tell the difference between what is awesome and what is a amazing story. Trust me it is one of my favorite sci-fi films but Mr. Cameron disappointed me with the story. It is no District 9 (which is my personal favorite sci-fi film), but it is better than Star Trek. The 3D wasn’t any thing special; Coraline’s was a 1,000 times better. The 3D bothered my eyes way too much. But the effects where unbelievable. I felt like I was actually there and the Na’vi felt real at times, like I couldn’t tell the actors apart from the Na’vi a few times.
The action was great, but again the story felt dull and unoriginal. Not the say I completely hated the story is that I’ve seen it done better. Cameron has done action with a great story I mean look at T-2, Arnold Schwarzenegger actually made people cry at the end of that movie, which is something we never saw coming. Avatar, yet having an amazing experience and effects, it still lacks in story, but it is still an amazing film. 7.5-8/10
2 comments:
Loved the writeup...Though I quite did not like the film at all. All it seemed was concentrated on getting the visual up.
Hey Ethan, I saw the movie on Christmas Day and had a similar experience... the effects and how they integrated into the 3-D format was awesome, and I was transported to another world. Yeah... he will win technical awards and maybe one for directing since he directed this monstrosity of a pic into being... just note the gargantuan credit roll poste-film. Me??? I'd highly recommend it since the film will be discussed and referenced for many years to come...and - there were definitely moments of magic in the film to behold. Cheers.
c. shoemaker
Post a Comment
ALL POSTS ARE MODERATED!